We Submit By Banning Blackmail

In an era where power dynamics shape our interactions, an ancient forager norm serves as a reminder of the importance of resisting domination. This timeless principle urges us to stand firm against coercion and manipulation, yet in practice, we often falter. Our words and public actions may defy oppressive forces, but when it comes to private, deniable, or costly acts, we tend to yield.

Around those in power, we often adopt ingratiating behaviors, laughing and agreeing more frequently, interrupting less, and being more deferential, polite, and flattering. We conform to the expectations of our bosses and are less likely to criticize them in the presence of others. This phenomenon is not unique to individuals; it extends to broader societal structures. Economic elites and organized business groups wield significant influence over government policy, while average citizens and mass-based interest groups have little to no independent sway.

The issue of blackmail has long been a focal point in discussions about power and resistance. Anti-blackmail laws, intended to protect individuals from coercion, often end up serving the interests of the wealthy and powerful. By criminalizing blackmail initiated by those with less power, these laws allow rich celebrities and elites to more easily evade norms and laws. This is evident in the treatment of non-disclosure agreements (NDAs), which are legal and acceptable when initiated by the rich, but are criminalized when initiated by those observing their transgressions.

The existence of such disparities highlights a systemic bias in favor of the powerful. The enforcement of anti-blackmail laws prioritizes the interests of the wealthy, enabling them to exploit their position and evade accountability. This raises questions about the true purpose of these laws and the underlying motivations driving their implementation.

In a society where power dynamics are deeply entrenched, the ancient forager norm serves as a stark reminder of the need to resist domination. While our public actions may defy oppressive forces, our private behaviors often reflect a willingness to yield to those in power. To truly uphold the principles of equality and justice, we must confront these disparities and strive for a system where all individuals, regardless of their status, are held accountable for their actions.

Ultimately, the struggle against blackmail and domination is a battle for the soul of our society. By recognizing the systemic biases that perpetuate power imbalances, we can work towards a more equitable world where the voices of the marginalized are heard, and the norms of fairness and justice are upheld. Only then can we truly submit by banning blackmail and resist the forces that seek to dominate and control us.