ICMSA: HSA rules on telescopic telehandlers ‘way over the top’

The Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association (ICMSA) has recently criticized the Health and Safety Authority (HSA) for imposing what it considers excessive training requirements for telescopic telehandlers. Pat O’Brien, chairperson of the farm business committee for ICMSA, highlighted that the majority of farmers are unaware of these new rules, which came into effect last September.

Under the HSA’s Code of Practice, farmers and their employees must undergo appropriate training to operate telescopic telehandlers, which are commonly used to lift items such as fertilizer bags, bales, and other heavy loads. There are approximately 4,000 telehandlers in use on Irish farms, and O’Brien emphasized that farmers remain uncertain about the varying requirements in different circumstances.

During a recent meeting with the HSA, O’Brien expressed concerns over the lack of awareness among farmers regarding the need for training. He argued that if a farmer or employee has not completed the required training and faces a legal case, they would be at the mercy of the judge. This highlights the potential legal risks associated with non-compliance.

Another major issue raised by O’Brien is the length and cost of the training. The proposed course duration is up to five days, with a minimum of three days required. The cost of the course itself could reach €1,000, and when factoring in wages and PRSI (Public Relief and Support Services), the total expense for an employee to complete the training could amount to €2,000. O’Brien described this cost as “ridiculous” and argued that it will “do nothing for farm safety.”

He further estimated that implementing these training requirements across all 4,000 telehandlers in Irish farms could cost around €4 million, assuming only one person per telehandler receives training. O’Brien called on the HSA to review the code’s training duration and cost, urging a reevaluation to ensure it is both practical and affordable for farmers.

ICMSA’s stance on the matter underscores the need for clearer communication about the HSA’s rules, particularly given the significant financial implications for farmers. The association’s concerns about the cost and duration of training suggest that the current requirements may not be sustainable or effective in promoting farm safety. As a result, the HSA may need to consider revising its approach to ensure a balance between safety and practicality for Irish farmers.