Europe's cloud minnows tell Brussels to stop big tech 'sovereignty-washing'

In a bold move to shape the future of European digital infrastructure, 24 executives from cloud and digital service providers across the continent have penned an open letter to the European Commission. The letter, which demands a focus on control-based definitions and reserved procurement, urges lawmakers to prioritize genuine tech sovereignty over the illusion of it in the upcoming Cloud and AI Development Act (CADA).

The executives, representing a diverse range of European cloud providers, argue that the current proposals for the CADA risk perpetuating a facade of sovereignty that does not fully protect European data and digital services from external threats. They contend that the proposed regulations should instead ensure that critical infrastructure and data remain under the control of European entities, safeguarding both national security and economic interests.

The open letter highlights the need for a clear definition of "control" in the context of digital services and infrastructure. The signatories emphasize that control should not merely be a legal or contractual concept but should reflect actual decision-making power and influence over data and operations. This, they argue, would prevent situations where European organizations are merely figureheads, with real power residing elsewhere.

Another key demand in the letter is the establishment of reserved procurement, a policy that would prioritize European providers in public sector contracts. This would help level the playing field and ensure that local businesses are not at a disadvantage when competing with global tech giants. The executives believe that such measures are essential to foster a competitive European digital ecosystem and to prevent the continent from becoming dependent on external providers.

The call for action comes as the European Commission prepares to finalize the CADA, a legislative package aimed at shaping the continent's approach to cloud computing and artificial intelligence. While the initiative is well-intentioned, the executives warn that it risks falling short of its goals if it does not address the core issues of control and sovereignty.

The open letter also underscores the importance of collaboration between European nations in establishing common standards and regulations. By working together, the signatories argue, the EU can create a unified front that protects its digital interests and enhances its global competitiveness. This would involve not only harmonizing legal frameworks but also investing in research and development to drive innovation and ensure technological leadership.

The executives' plea is a stark reminder of the challenges faced by European cloud providers in the shadow of dominant global tech companies. While these companies offer valuable services, they often operate from outside the EU, raising concerns about data privacy and national security. The open letter seeks to address these concerns by ensuring that European digital infrastructure remains under the control of local entities, thereby promoting economic self-sufficiency and technological independence.

In response to the letter, the European Commission has acknowledged the concerns raised by the executives. Officials have stated that the CADA will be shaped through extensive consultation with stakeholders, including industry representatives, academics, and civil society organizations. The Commission has also pledged to prioritize transparency and inclusivity in the legislative process, ensuring that all voices are heard and that the final regulations serve the best interests of European citizens and businesses.

As the debate over the CADA continues, the open letter from the 24 European executives serves as a clarion call for a more assertive approach to tech sovereignty. By prioritizing control and reserved procurement, the EU can create a digital landscape that is both secure and competitive, one that empowers European businesses and safeguards national interests in an increasingly interconnected world.